https://www.big-8.org/w/index.php?action=history&feed=atom&title=Nan%3A2010-10-02-lcc-rec.arts.books.reviews 2026-04-30T04:17:33Z Revision history for this page on the wiki MediaWiki 1.43.1 https://www.big-8.org/w/index.php?title=Nan:2010-10-02-lcc-rec.arts.books.reviews&diff=1572&oldid=prev 2010-10-02T21:21:01Z

<p>Created page with &quot;&lt;pre&gt; From: Big-8 Management Board &lt;board@big-8.org&gt; Subject: RFD: rec.arts.books.reviews moderated (remove) LAST CALL FOR COMMENTS Date: Sat, 2 Oct 2010 08:27:37 EDT Message-ID:...&quot;</p> <p><b>New page</b></p><div>&lt;pre&gt;<br /> From: Big-8 Management Board &lt;board@big-8.org&gt;<br /> Subject: RFD: rec.arts.books.reviews moderated (remove) LAST CALL FOR COMMENTS<br /> Date: Sat, 2 Oct 2010 08:27:37 EDT<br /> Message-ID: &lt;i86ucu$94v$1@news.albasani.net&gt;<br /> <br /> REQUEST FOR DISCUSSION (RFD)<br /> moderated group rec.arts.books.reviews<br /> <br /> This is a formal Request for Discussion (RFD) to remove moderated<br /> newsgroup rec.arts.books.reviews.<br /> <br /> RATIONALE:<br /> <br /> According to Google&#039;s archive the last regular post was approved on<br /> 2006-12-05. A probe message showed no result.<br /> <br /> Miguel Farah posted in news.groups.proposals that the moderation is<br /> not abandoned, yet the group is dead for all intents and purposes.<br /> He thinks the newsgroup should be removed.<br /> <br /> &gt; &gt;Message-ID: &lt;c4e91aae-3360-4dfd-bb8a-e76eb2d25e89@w30g2000yqw.googlegroups.com&gt;<br /> NEWSGROUPS LINE:<br /> <br /> rec.arts.books.reviews Book reviews. (Moderated)<br /> <br /> DISTRIBUTION:<br /> <br /> news.announce.newgroups<br /> news.groups.proposals<br /> rec.arts.books.reviews<br /> rec.arts.books<br /> <br /> CHARTER OF REC.ARTS.BOOKS.REVIEWS<br /> <br /> The purpose of this group is to carry reviews of books. A review<br /> consists of commentary on a book by someone who has read the book<br /> designed to help those who have not read it make an informed decision<br /> as to whether or not to do so. <br /> <br /> This newsgroup will be a moderated group.<br /> <br /> The following materials will appear in the group:<br /> <br /> - Reviews of written works<br /> - Descriptions of reviewer philosophy or background<br /> <br /> The following are not appropriate for the group:<br /> <br /> - Discussion of books<br /> - Announcements of book availability<br /> - Advertisements and promotional materials<br /> - Requests that a particular book be reviewed<br /> <br /> Reviewers who have a financial interest in the books they review<br /> should state this fact in their reviews.<br /> <br /> Moderator: <br /> <br /> The moderator will be Steve Brock &lt;brock@ucsub.colorado.edu&gt;.<br /> The backup moderator will be Danny Yee &lt;danny@staff.cs.su.oz.au&gt;.<br /> <br /> The submissions address is book-reviews@colorado.edu. There is no<br /> special contact address. <br /> <br /> Moderation policy:<br /> <br /> The function of moderation is to ensure that only reviews and related<br /> materials appear in the group. <br /> <br /> - Reviews must contain some details. For example, &quot;XXX is a great<br /> book!&quot; is not a review.<br /> <br /> - Posts will never be rejected on the basis of relevant content,<br /> but the moderator would reject (for example) a post that<br /> pretended to be a book review of _Lord of the Rings_ but was<br /> actually an excuse for an anti-Armenian diatribe.<br /> <br /> - A review MUST clearly indicate the title, author and publisher<br /> of the book. A book review SHOULD contain the length,<br /> publication date, ISBN, price, and subject or keywords. The<br /> more bibliographic data the better. No specific format will be<br /> required for this data, though some format may be encouraged. <br /> <br /> - Posters should crosspost reviews into rec.arts.books and other<br /> relevant groups. Followups should be directed to the<br /> appropriate group(s) (rec.arts.books if nowhere else is<br /> suitable). The moderator may modify the Followup-To: header if<br /> necessary, perhaps after consultation with the author.<br /> <br /> - Reviews by people with vested interests will be permitted<br /> provided that they are substantive and that reviewers make<br /> explicit any financial connection they have with the subject of<br /> their review. <br /> <br /> HISTORY OF THE GROUP:<br /> <br /> rec.arts.books.reviews is a moderated newsgroup which passed its vote for<br /> creation by 286:6 as reported in news.announce.newgroups on 1 Nov 1994.<br /> <br /> PROPONENT:<br /> <br /> Alexander Bartolich &lt;alexander.bartolich@gmx.at&gt;<br /> <br /> PROCEDURE:<br /> <br /> Those who wish to comment on this request to remove this newsgroup should<br /> subscribe to news.groups.proposals and participate in the relevant threads<br /> in that newsgroup.<br /> <br /> To this end, the followup header of this RFD has been set to<br /> news.groups.proposals.<br /> <br /> In the course of the removal process four formal announcements are posted<br /> (MVI, 1st RFD, 2nd RFD, and LCC), each taking two weeks. At the end of the<br /> process the B8MB will vote on the issue.<br /> <br /> Available options for rec.arts.books.reviews are:<br /> - leave the group as it is<br /> - remove the group<br /> <br /> For more information on the removal process, please see <br /> <br /> http://www.big-8.org/wiki/Group_Removal_FAQ<br /> <br /> CHANGE HISTORY:<br /> <br /> 2010-04-05 First probe post<br /> 2010-08-09 Moderator Vacancy Investigation<br /> 2010-08-23 1st RFD<br /> 2010-09-06 2nd RFD<br /> 2010-10-02 LCC<br /> &lt;/pre&gt;</div>

Alba